Consignment / PSA
Consignment & PSA Grading
PSA Authorized DealerSell your cards hassle-free or send them in for PSA grading — we handle everything from submission to payout.
PSA Authorized Submission Center
Recent submission returns
×
![PSA graded slab enlarged]()
Review & Prep fee
$5 per card
Payment timing
Invoiced on return
Return shipping
Free (cards in-store) · $5 (PSA-only)
Order tracking
Live spreadsheet on our website
Service levels
Value Bulk
$32 / card
Max card value: $500
Est. 65 business days
Popular
Value Plus
$60 / card
Max card value: $500
Est. 25 business days
Regular
$95 / card
Max card value: $1,500
Est. 15 business days
Express
$190 / card
Max card value: $2,500
Est. 10 business days
Super Express
$355 / card
Max card value: $5,000
Est. 5 business days
Walkthrough
$680 / card
Max card value: $10,000
Est. 5 business days
Estimated turnaround times begin once your order is entered into the PSA grading system — not when we receive your cards. We'll notify you when your cards arrive back from PSA. Please hold off on reaching out for updates while the live spreadsheet is active.
How to submit
1
Drop off or mail in
Bring cards to our shop in Onalaska or mail them to the address below. Include your name and contact info in the package.
2
We review & prep
Cards are inspected and prepped for submission at $5 per card. We handle the PSA submission process entirely.
3
Track on our live spreadsheet
Once your order is live in the PSA system, a tracking spreadsheet is available directly on our website.
4
Get your cards back
We'll notify you when your graded cards are returned. Payment is collected via invoice at that point.
Mailing address
Ship to
Badger Sports Shop
ATTN: Consignment
336 2nd Avenue South
Onalaska, WI 54650
ATTN: Consignment
336 2nd Avenue South
Onalaska, WI 54650
Why consign with us?
✓
47,000+ items sold — we know how to move cards
With 99.9% positive feedback on eBay, your cards are in proven hands. Buyers trust us, which means better prices for you.
✓
We handle everything
Listing, photography, buyer communication — fully managed on eBay so you don't have to lift a finger.
✓
Maximum return, minimum effort
Cards from breaks listed same day or within a couple days. Mail-ins listed within a week.
✓
Reward points bonus
Request store rewards instead of cash and earn 3% back on your total payout.
Payout rates
Rates are based on each card's individual final sale price — not the lot total.
| Final sale price | Your payout |
|---|---|
| $1 – $50 | 80% − $0.99 fee |
| $50 – $99.99 | 81% |
| $100 – $999.99 | 82% |
| $1,000 – $2,499 | 84% |
| $2,500 – $4,999.99 | 85% |
| $5,000+ | 90% |
Cards sold under $9.99 are subject to a $0.99 listing fee. Items with no bids are charged a $2 unsold fee and kept in-house. Unpaid sales are relisted 1–2 weeks after the auction ends.
How it works
1
Submit your cards
Fill out the consignment form, include it in your mail-in package, or stop by the shop. For break items, use the break listing form.
2
We list on eBay
All items start at $0.99 auction. Break cards go live same day or within a couple days; lots of 50+ get an estimated date from us.
3
Track your items
We maintain a spreadsheet of every item including final sale price and your payout. Available on request.
4
Get paid every Wednesday
Payouts via PayPal, Venmo, or Cash App. We'll reach out with your total every Wednesday.
Conditions
- ○Raw cards must be near mint or mint condition. All graded cards accepted.
- ○No altered cards of any kind.
- ○Zero tolerance for shill bidding — results in a permanent ban.
- ○Returned cards due to damage may result in you owing the difference in value.
Get started
Contact
Email
Facebook
Badger Consignment
Please allow processing time before reaching out about payouts. Our team will contact you every Wednesday with your payout details.
Mailing address
Ship to
Ba
Follow
Sign up to get the latest on sales, new releases and more …
© 2026 Badger Breaks.
Powered by Shopify
